Monthly Investor Letter, September 2022

“The end of Fed tightening will come when something breaks, and from where I sit cracks are forming.” -- Scott Minerd, Global CIO of Guggenheim Partners

Cracks Are Forming

It’s only half-joking when growth investors are banging their heads against a wall and begging for a recession these days. The irony behind their longing is that it might take a recession, or something broken, to force the Fed to end this front-loaded hiking campaign from which growth assets suffer the most. Whatever the pain a recession possibly brings could be well offset by loosening financial conditions. That’s the expectation, at least.

This is not the typical cycle-ending hiking play that we are used to, like the most recent experience we had at the end of 2018 (Chart 1). The Fed put its blunt monetary policy tool on the show, which has been aggressively slowing down the demand growth as measured by the inventory/sales ratio and ISM PMI. In normal times, these cracks are bad enough for the Fed to pivot. Not this time around: the elevated CPI print keeps the Fed at bay. Throughout August and September, the message from the Fed is loud and clear: not so early.

Chart 1

article
The U.S. Business Cycle vs. Inflation

This new dynamic leaves investors with a risky scenario that they haven’t experienced before. What if the Fed’s tolerance for deteriorating fundamentals is much higher than usual? In other words, the negative EPS revisions (more than often a lagging indicator) could hit investors before the Fed loosens up. That alone could amplify the equities’ downside risk even from today’s level.

Chart 2

article
Nasdaq 100 Forward EPS Revisions (Peak to Trough) of Historical Scenarios

To quantify the potential impact, we studied the full magnitude of EPS revisions of QQQ, from peak to trough, during each recession or near-recession scenario since the dot-com bubble (Chart 2). Outside the severe recessions (2008 and the dot-com bubble), the worst revision was 11% during the global pandemic lockdown in 2020. As of October 07, 2022, the current EPS revision from the peak is already 3.7%. It certainly looks scarier when we are in deep recessions. However, the catch is that the Fed could have turned around way before the complete negative revision materialized. It’s not a stretched assumption, in our opinion.

Nike’s Quarter, A Bad Omen

We pick on Nike’s recent quarter as a good case in point that fundamentals have been deteriorating fast. Nike reported its Fiscal Q1 results in late September. The quarter was fine. Small beats on both revenue and EPS, although a slight miss to gross margin. What caught investors off guard was its forward-looking guidance. Blaming the strong dollar, the management now sees sales dollar growth of low-to-mid-single digits for the year, compared to its previous guidance of +6% to 8%. Yes, the dollar was strong, which put one-time pressure on dollar-denominated sales, but could it also be the softening of demand?

What’s more, inventory was high. Nike's inventory in North America increased by 65% in the last quarter versus last year, while the entire company was up 44%. After the supply chain disruptions through the pandemic, Nike decided to place orders early from its Asian vendors; as the shipping glut eased, old and new orders were arriving simultaneously. This is not surprising. Lululemon experienced pretty much the same. The market did not take this development well.

The Fed, Case for Caution?

More prominent voices have joined the growing list that calls the Fed’s aggressive hiking for caution. To be clear, nobody is expecting a near-term “pivot” as being misplaced and abused by financial media lately. The market expects the Fed to be more mindful of unintended consequences after three jumbo 75bps hikes in a row. Financial stability is as important as keeping inflation in check at this juncture.

“We also recognize that liquidity is a little fragile in core markets and so we’re carefully monitoring liquidity conditions in those markets.” -- Lael Brainard, Federal Reserve Vice Chair

We made a case that the Fed was no longer behind the curve. It takes time for the Fed’s tightening actions to impact economic activities and, eventually, prices. We found the curvature of the yield curve (3M2Y10Y butterfly as a proxy) has been very informative regarding whether the Fed has been keeping up with inflation expectations. By this measure, the Fed is tighter than inflation expectations could justify now (Chart 3).

Chart 3

article
Yield Curve Shape vs. ISM Price Paid

LETTERS

Esoterica's statements are not an endorsement of any company or a recommendation to buy, sell or hold any security. For full disclosures, click here.

Get the most lucid takes on where things are headed

Articles and educational writing for smarter investing.

How to Build a Three-Fund Portfolio
How to Build a Three-Fund Portfolio
How to Build a Three-Fund Portfolio
How to Build a Three-Fund Portfolio
How to Build a Three-Fund Portfolio
How to Build a Three-Fund Portfolio
How to Build a Three-Fund Portfolio
How to Build a Three-Fund Portfolio
How to Build a Three-Fund Portfolio
How to Build a Three-Fund Portfolio
How to Build a Three-Fund Portfolio
How to Build a Three-Fund Portfolio
How to Build a Three-Fund Portfolio
How to Build a Three-Fund Portfolio
How to Build a Three-Fund Portfolio
How to Build a Three-Fund Portfolio
How to Build a Three-Fund Portfolio
How to Build a Three-Fund Portfolio
How to Build a Three-Fund Portfolio
How to Build a Three-Fund Portfolio
How to Build a Three-Fund Portfolio
How to Build a Three-Fund Portfolio
How to Build a Three-Fund Portfolio
How to Build a Three-Fund Portfolio
How to Build a Three-Fund Portfolio
How to Build a Three-Fund Portfolio
How to Build a Three-Fund Portfolio
How to Build a Three-Fund Portfolio
How to Build a Three-Fund Portfolio
How to Build a Three-Fund Portfolio
How to Build a Three-Fund Portfolio
How to Build a Three-Fund Portfolio
How to Build a Three-Fund Portfolio
How to Build a Three-Fund Portfolio
How to Build a Three-Fund Portfolio
How to Build a Three-Fund Portfolio
How to Build a Three-Fund Portfolio
How to Build a Three-Fund Portfolio
How to Build a Three-Fund Portfolio
How to Build a Three-Fund Portfolio
How to Build a Three-Fund Portfolio
How to Build a Three-Fund Portfolio
How to Build a Three-Fund Portfolio
How to Build a Three-Fund Portfolio
How to Build a Three-Fund Portfolio
How to Build a Three-Fund Portfolio
How to Build a Three-Fund Portfolio
How to Build a Three-Fund Portfolio
How to Build a Three-Fund Portfolio
How to Build a Three-Fund Portfolio

Asset Allocation for Diversification
Asset Allocation for Diversification
Asset Allocation for Diversification
Asset Allocation for Diversification
Asset Allocation for Diversification
Asset Allocation for Diversification
Asset Allocation for Diversification
Asset Allocation for Diversification
Asset Allocation for Diversification
Asset Allocation for Diversification
Asset Allocation for Diversification
Asset Allocation for Diversification
Asset Allocation for Diversification
Asset Allocation for Diversification
Asset Allocation for Diversification
Asset Allocation for Diversification
Asset Allocation for Diversification
Asset Allocation for Diversification
Asset Allocation for Diversification
Asset Allocation for Diversification
Asset Allocation for Diversification
Asset Allocation for Diversification
Asset Allocation for Diversification
Asset Allocation for Diversification
Asset Allocation for Diversification
Asset Allocation for Diversification
Asset Allocation for Diversification
Asset Allocation for Diversification
Asset Allocation for Diversification
Asset Allocation for Diversification
Asset Allocation for Diversification
Asset Allocation for Diversification
Asset Allocation for Diversification
Asset Allocation for Diversification
Asset Allocation for Diversification
Asset Allocation for Diversification
Asset Allocation for Diversification
Asset Allocation for Diversification
Asset Allocation for Diversification
Asset Allocation for Diversification
Asset Allocation for Diversification
Asset Allocation for Diversification
Asset Allocation for Diversification
Asset Allocation for Diversification
Asset Allocation for Diversification
Asset Allocation for Diversification
Asset Allocation for Diversification
Asset Allocation for Diversification
Asset Allocation for Diversification
Asset Allocation for Diversification

How to Measure Economic Cycles
How to Measure Economic Cycles
How to Measure Economic Cycles
How to Measure Economic Cycles
How to Measure Economic Cycles
How to Measure Economic Cycles
How to Measure Economic Cycles
How to Measure Economic Cycles
How to Measure Economic Cycles
How to Measure Economic Cycles
How to Measure Economic Cycles
How to Measure Economic Cycles
How to Measure Economic Cycles
How to Measure Economic Cycles
How to Measure Economic Cycles
How to Measure Economic Cycles
How to Measure Economic Cycles
How to Measure Economic Cycles
How to Measure Economic Cycles
How to Measure Economic Cycles
How to Measure Economic Cycles
How to Measure Economic Cycles
How to Measure Economic Cycles
How to Measure Economic Cycles
How to Measure Economic Cycles
How to Measure Economic Cycles
How to Measure Economic Cycles
How to Measure Economic Cycles
How to Measure Economic Cycles
How to Measure Economic Cycles
How to Measure Economic Cycles
How to Measure Economic Cycles
How to Measure Economic Cycles
How to Measure Economic Cycles
How to Measure Economic Cycles
How to Measure Economic Cycles
How to Measure Economic Cycles
How to Measure Economic Cycles
How to Measure Economic Cycles
How to Measure Economic Cycles
How to Measure Economic Cycles
How to Measure Economic Cycles
How to Measure Economic Cycles
How to Measure Economic Cycles
How to Measure Economic Cycles
How to Measure Economic Cycles
How to Measure Economic Cycles
How to Measure Economic Cycles
How to Measure Economic Cycles
How to Measure Economic Cycles

What Is GDP
What Is GDP
What Is GDP
What Is GDP
What Is GDP
What Is GDP
What Is GDP
What Is GDP
What Is GDP
What Is GDP
What Is GDP
What Is GDP
What Is GDP
What Is GDP
What Is GDP
What Is GDP
What Is GDP
What Is GDP
What Is GDP
What Is GDP
What Is GDP
What Is GDP
What Is GDP
What Is GDP
What Is GDP
What Is GDP
What Is GDP
What Is GDP
What Is GDP
What Is GDP
What Is GDP
What Is GDP
What Is GDP
What Is GDP
What Is GDP
What Is GDP
What Is GDP
What Is GDP
What Is GDP
What Is GDP
What Is GDP
What Is GDP
What Is GDP
What Is GDP
What Is GDP
What Is GDP
What Is GDP
What Is GDP
What Is GDP
What Is GDP

How we can work together

See Our Solutions

Next

Generation

Investing

©2020, Esoterica Capital LLC (“ESOTERICA”). All content is original and has been researched and produced by ESOTERICA unless otherwise stated. No part of ESOTERICA’s original content may be reproduced in any form, or referred to in any other publication, without the express written permission of ESOTERICA. The content is for informational and educational purposes only and should not be construed as investment advice or an offer or solicitation in respect to any products or services for any persons who are prohibited from receiving such information under the laws applicable to their place of citizenship, domicile or residence.



Certain of the statements contained on this website may be statements of future expectations and other forward-looking statements that are based on ESOTERICA's current views and assumptions, and involve known and unknown risks and uncertainties that could cause actual results, performance or events to differ materially from those expressed or implied in such statements. All content is subject to change without notice. All statements made regarding companies or securities or other financial information on this site or any sites relating to ESOTERICA are strictly beliefs and points of view held by ESOTERICA or the third party making such statement and are not endorsements by ESOTERICA of any company or security or recommendations by ESOTERICA to buy, sell or hold any security. The content presented does not constitute investment advice, should not be used as the basis for any investment decision, and does not purport to provide any legal, tax or accounting advice. Please remember that there are inherent risks involved with investing in the markets, and your investments may be worth more or less than your initial investment upon redemption. There is no guarantee that ESOTERICA's objectives will be achieved. Further, there is no assurance that any strategies, methods, sectors, or any investment programs herein were or will prove to be profitable, or that any investment recommendations or decisions we make in the future will be profitable for any investor or client. Professional money management is not suitable for all investors. For full disclosures, please go to our Terms & Conditions page.